-
Website
http://www.chrisbrogan.com/ -
Original page
http://www.chrisbrogan.com/a-crash-course-in-comments/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
Ari Herzog
120 comments · 23 points
-
Don Lafferty
59 comments · 3 points
-
Danny Brown
77 comments · 28 points
-
Dale Cruse
65 comments · 2 points
-
gerardmclean
43 comments · 7 points
-
-
Popular Threads
-
While the Iron is Hot
1 day ago · 60 comments
-
I Was Wrong About Twitter Lists
2 days ago · 64 comments
-
The Visible Media Maker
1 day ago · 23 comments
-
Simplicity Trumps Most Other Emotions
3 days ago · 53 comments
-
How to Make Goals Happen- Part 1 – GoalBox
5 days ago · 65 comments
-
While the Iron is Hot
These tips are really handy .. thank you!
Sue
The editor part is the main thing that I miss when blogging. I need someone to say, "Cut this" or "That is too many words," I really miss that.
I try and comment whenever possible. I am still figuring out my blog. I want to go in so many directions but I can't seem to write a short post. I include pictures and video but it just does not ever seem to be cut down enough.
Jamie
- dialog (answer as many comments as possible)
- plugins (subscribe to comments, commentluv, keywordluv, etc.)
- return the favor (get out and comment)
There were a couple of bonus "ingredients" as well that included reaching out to other bloggers via links and asking your readers questions.
These steps have helped me build a growing community of people and I have a few more to implement from your list now.
i've found this really useful and highly recommend it for any bloggers getting started.
I've done exactly what I do with worthy posts like this, share in every possible way.
The list presented is awesome digestible material to really take a look at one's blog and say: "Am I doing everything I can & should be doing" - my favorite quip the past few days: What POSITIVE VALUE am I generating for my readers and subscribers. That extends into leaving comments, tweets, videos, audio - it has to asked: "Are you creating Positive Value" to engage people with? I have to say that you are doing this quite well. Thanks for all the info you share with us!
Nice post, I needed to be reminded, thanks.
Should we prefer comments over trackbacks? Is there a conscious technique you adapt to get one vs the other?
Also, I notice you don't have disqus built in to get the aggregate of comments here, why? Is there a reason you don't have mybloglog to track who is visiting here?
@Bill - sorry about that. I do try to make these types of posts a bit "checklisty," so you can at least run through, give yourself a diagnostic checkup, and then run from there. Hey, you can always eschew every piece of advice above and be a lamer like PerezHilton.com . (Lamer like wayyyyyyyyy more traffic than me). : )
@Steve Hopkins - can you explain that a bit more. Might be because it's almost 3AM, but I missed it.
@Lots of you - editors are truly what a lot of us need. Even me. Especially me.
Thanks!
Would love to hear your thoughts on readers who prefer to comment via e-mail, rather than on the blog. Even though I think that I've made commenting as easy as possible it's one of my biggest challenges right now, and they have always been comments that would add positively to the discussion on my blog (not info that people would prefer to keep private). I frequently reference them in subsequent posts - "a reader asked me..." type thing - but it can be frustrating to receive so many comments via e-mail that no one but me ever sees.
And I do indeed believe the integration of visuals into a mostly text-related post enhances it for the viewer. Quick question:
How do you encourage those who are reading via RSS / mobile to easily comment? Suggestions for that as well?
Cheers from Indonesia.
For 'those what comment' I would recommend getting a gravatar and using the same pic across your web presences and 'comment streams' to have 'brand consistency'.
@javajive - I get 3-4x more readers in RSS than directly (which is flipped from most sites, I'm told), and yet I get a decent amount of comments. My advice from above is how I get them. Not sure if there's *more* that I'd recommend doing to try and pull people out of the RSS feed. I sure don't like partial feeds.
@Steve Nimmons - agreed, though only usually in the nerd crowd. Meaning, if you blog about fashion or yarn or whatever, prolly not. Agree?
I did learn that you can import the older comments into the system and it is highly recommended to back up your blog's database. That way if something goes wrong it can be restored. In your case with all the comments you have, I would go the extra step and back up the site to your computer as a secondary precaution. (in addition to the primary back up)
Another option ... probably the safest ... wait until Disqus has a better way to import old comments ;-) ... Scott
If I leave a quality comment on a blog and the author doesn't reply to it, I usually NEVER visit that blog again especially if they are considered popular or of stature. Most people that horde around the "big blogs" are sheep leaving comments--respecting people based on popularity--a reflection of cheapened values, greed and self-promotion. My friends always come first even if they write about kitty cats or their new haircut. :smile:
@Mary - that's a great feature, and I'm sure your community looks forward to it every week.
I appreciate you, I appreciate your reminders. I haven't been as diligent as I was when I first paddled out to surf the social and new media wave. Your post reminded me to start getting barreled, to flash a shaka to someone who wrote a great post and give, give, give.
Aloha,
NEENZ.
Threaded comments helps creating a small community forum around posts.
It's much easier for people to reply to each other this way.
Your reply means a lot to me. Have a great day :smile:
I had a real problem that I tend to write my How To type post to complete and people say that there was not really anything to add. I have been working on that! My post also tend to be long, then again so are some of my comments.LOL
I will say that the more I get out and comment the more comments I get back.
I will be working on these things.
I am now off to see what your other commenters' are doing on their blogs. I will follow a link from a comment faster than I will if it is just sent out via a stream.
I need to figure out a way to have certain posts resent to me every month or so. I read this, use the great ideas about installing comment software, and take away a great reminder about writing shorter articles. That lasts about a week and then I start to ramble again. The constant reminder to write breifly and to the point always helps.
Conor
2nd. you could have titled this "how to be authentic in conversation/life/relationships.'
can't you see it now? tshirts that say 'bloggers do it better" seriously: one has to want to connect with thoughts...and invite them, welcome tem, nurture them, respect and honor them. (she says assertively after writing a rather talking at post today...errrf). good reminders.
what device do you use when leaving comments/vs when you tweet? laptop for both? same laptop or 2? or a mobile device? just interested b/c your timing is rather cool on both.
happy real first day of the new president.
Thanks for those tips mate, looking to do/ and get more blog comments so thanks once again for your handy tips :)
Cheers,
Matt
You've always been the master of eliciting comments by asking questions at the end of your posts.
Two points:
1. The more I write, the more I learn. For me commenting helps me process the information.
2. Have you heard of backttype? Big benefit is that it captures all the comments you make across the web. I use a nice little sidebar widget that displays comments like this one back on my blog. For those afraid of wasting keystrokes on someone else blog this makes every keystroke enhance your blog. Also shows folks that you are engaged in a broader community of bloggers. Take a peak at http://www.tourismkeys.ca/blog
When I first started, I didn't have a clue what I was doing from a STRATEGY standpoint..I was just following @jowyang's blog and commenting like crazy because I thought what he was saying was just so incredibly helpful and important to my industry-furniture.
Then, through him, I found you. You were so helpful to me when I was just starting on twitter and I haven't forgotten that.
Then, emotionally, I REALLY connected with you(although you didn't know it) the day I saw your video re: your feelings after attending the Orlando tweetup. That's when I realized that you really very sincere.
Then, when you went through the firestorm re: your sponsored blog post, I supported you and tweeted everyone who was dissing you which was the only way I knew to help you. I commented like crazy on blog postings, tweeted a LOT, etc.
So, everything you have said in this latest post rings so true for me. My connections to so many have come simply through curiousity, quest for learning, understanding the power of love AND business that is unleashed through blog comments, twitter RT's, linkedin comments, facebook updates and social bookmarking sites(still learning that one) and commentiing on great video sites. It's the linking and helping that create value for all of us and will, I strongly believe, be the key to creating the jobs of the future.
I won't tell you that you are my favorite rock star along with @jowyang because you already know that ! Thank you for being you.
Thanks :-)
http://churchcrunch.com/2008/11/27/top-five-com...
It's so interesting to be able to see what people where people, people you follow say on Twitter or elsewhere, leave comments. And ofcourse what they write.
I have found many a new blog or website through tracking comments by the people I am following on Backtype.
I use the Twitter option to post a daily update of my own comments left, so it encourages people to check what is interesting to me that day.
Every post I read, come across or see on a RT, that I find interesting is ALWAYS bookmarked in Delicious and more often than not given a Thumbs up. As you say, it only takes moments. And will do this even if I have not left an actual comment.
So leaving comments are not the only way to show your appreciation which is the best thing about these other services, you can use what fits in with your routine.
Great post,
Graham
Sneaky I know, but it serves a purpose which is to help promote the sites I participate in. Including this comment here, people that follow me on Twitter and Backtype will see I have left two comments here today, which should then push more traffic here.
Everyone wins. :)
I have used Disqus and liked it. I also like Intense Debate. It is a very solid system and has worked well on my blog.
I do follow most of the listed points above. The editor thing is what I really miss as my english is not that perfect and English is not my mother language, I read my posts twice before posting them and sometimes If somebody is next to me I do let him/her review it. Also since I knew this blog, my posts are getting a better look and always implementing new stuff and strategies but still no comments.
As for me I always try to comment on posts I like or share them through my tweetdeck and blog. Hope I can find what is wrong with my blog to enhance it and get it to a better level.
Should I quit blogging? Change my blog layout? Do some SEO? what should be done?
Again, and again thank you chris for another great post.
Cheers!
Jean
Rock on, Chris, rock on. I've been digging (well not technically per say, but) what you've been blogging since I found your site a couple of months back.
Scott Schroeder | @scottalk
Everything you said here is great. I think for me the main point is to leave a well thought out comment that adds value to the post. Then other bloggers will naturally want to reciprocate. This keeps it from seeming spammy and often times encourages them to return the favor. It's goes along with your give to get point.
Many people don't have digg accounts etc, it will be great to have a built-in post rating. Users can come and just say 'yes i like it', 'that's a terrible post' or 'no pain no gain'.. Easier than getting a comment, offers some interactivity to your users and they don't need to have a digg / stumbleupon account (though those certainly have much more value than just internal rating).
I have had many 'lurkers' who have been following the blog for a long time but never bother to comment, a simple statement like: I would like to hear from my readers about what they think about 'some topic' has gotten some of the lurkers to become active participants.
Gravatar is often good, I have also tried 'defaulting' Notify me of followup comments on a blog and though some people got annoyed, others 'noticed' the option for the first time :)) (It's not a webmaster blog).
What I DO do, though, is star the stuff I want to remember in Google Reader, and share the stuff I really like with folks, including my Google Talk friends. It's not perfect, but it's quick.
The timeliness of your posts are like you're in my head. So often we expect to get comments by just throwing our textual spaghetti to the wall. If it sticks, we get comments. If it hits the floor, someone is scowling at us as they scroll by. Thanks again for the information. (I tried really hard not to say, "Great post!" even though it was.
Have a Wonderful Day!
I'm always amazed how you live online. I'll be up late on the West Coast and you are still conversing away.
You are a Social Media Maven, Connector and Salesman. You sir are the tipping point. ;)
I think the tactic of giving comments is underrated. I know many people that only comment on their own blogs and never make it outside their own comment garden - which is not the same as participating on another domain or blog.
I noticed you do not use a third party comment system which obviously lowers the barrier to people potentially commenting. I am obviously biased towards Disqus, and think it would make a great addition. I understand your fears of losing previous comments, but hopefully there can be a rock solid solution for transferring things over and hopefully we can find one.
You are the king of Twitter and my mind is spinning trying to learn all this, but your blog has definitely given me vision on how this all works. I have been stumbling around wondering what I am supposed to do. You probably come across a lot of tweeple like me and wonder what the heck we are doing!
@123
@234
when you want to respond to someone specifically.
it's true though when you comment anywhere, majority of the time they will return the favor, come back to your website, read your material, and then put in their 2 cents.
for new bloggers it's important that they read more than they write, comment more than they expect people to comment on theirs. like you said, gotta give to get. .i like this post Chris.
I'm amazed at how useful comments can be, and the different perspectives they bring to the post.
I need to be spending a lot more time commenting, and this is a wonderful reminder of WHY.
Well said!
Hope you are well.
Best.
William
www.williamarruda.com
Thanks for the great post. I was just tweeting today about how I had more views than normal but no comments. Thanks for the inspiration!
@KFred85
Give to get. Practice social sharing. I'll be passing this one on to all of the bloggers in my life. Heck, I already tweeted it, which is one kind of comment.
I love that your posts become social objects or artifacts as a result of your questions and community. As you always point out, there's so much value in the audience building upon what you've started. That's the principle that Wikipedia operates upon, after all. Collective learning, collaborative editing and social proof. Whoda thought you'd find that on a pirate ship?
Because it seems that many people confuse me with a recruiter, however, I often get comments asking me to help them find a job. It can be awkward - I'm often torn between answering them on the blog itself, directly via email, or simply deleting the comment altogether....any advice?
This is just great grounding advice especially for someone (like myself) just hitting the ground running in the blogging world. Many thanks!!
It was great catching up with you at CES! We should encourage the "cab-sharing" trend at the next event. (SXSW?)
Its very "green" and a great way to socialize and make new friends! Thanks again!
@ElizabethHannan
http://tinyurl.com/2w8cvd
I also didn't respond to comments because I don't want to come across as "too wordy" - which I'm afraid I already do with my posts. I keep trying to cut them down - but when I go to edit the posts, it seems like everything is important and I can't cut anything out without losing important parts.
Lots to think about, though - and I sincerely appreciate it! Good timing as well - I will take this with me as I launch my new site.
Thanks for this post. I am just starting and getting off on the right foot is wonderful!
Thanks
Chris, thanks for your insight. It has been great following your blog and your posts on Twitter!
By the way, can I just say that links on your site are a bit hard to discern? The underline almost fades out next to the text. Otherwise I really appreciate your new blog design ;)
I have been thinking about using a tool like disqus but i have yet to really be convinced to install it on my blog. I bet before long I'll add it.
In the end comenting on relevent blogs is the best thing to do. Probably %75 of my hits come from people who click through from another blog to check my stuff out. It's time consuming but I'm learning and coming up with more ideas for me to write about when I read other posts.
Excellent post. I also found this posting from Problogger helpful on generating blog comments.
It states "Jakob Nielsen’s latest study finds that 90% of online community users are lurkers (read or observe without contributing) with only 9% of users contributing ‘a little’ and 1% actively contributing. So 1% of your blog’s users are actively engaging with your blog and the rest are at best occasional contributers."
It offers advice like "invite comments, ask questions, be humble and be open ended." And even though it's from 2006, it's still relevant today.
You can find it here the full post here http://www.problogger.net/archives/2006/10/12/1...
Comments form the basis of a great community, and you should see a correlation between the number of commentators and your "bounce rates" (with respect to site stats).
Providing a method of user participation is one method of reducing your bounce rates.
All of your points above give the reasons why.
Many thanks.
Chris
Ok ok, my thoughts - I've utilized a lot of these points and they make a HUGE difference on the interaction you get on your blog. One of the things I've remained true to, although it would be difficult for you Chris and the amount of comments you get, is to reply to every commenter through email and thank them for stopping by and add some addtl thoughts. I think it helps in building that relationship between blogger and reader - I think highly of people who have done that to me so I can only hope others enjoy a personal response as well.
I'm new to blogging. Reading a LOT more of them these days, and just put my first one up. Here's what I need to be more aware of:
Double Vision
Brevity rules
Ask questions
Promote others
Tom
In my situation, I speak on the topics of green and sustainability. So, I'll get comments on 'greenwashing.' That's cool. If we don't attract all views, how can we create positive change.
Chris, while I enjoy your blog, its not much help if I say, "Wow Chris, great post:), you've nailed it, you the man, nobody touches you in the blog-sphere!" Then you begin to lose your edge. You start to think you are the man.
So, I just gonna say thanks and leave it at that. Cool?
Jeff
I am curios, if you don't use CAPTCHA, how do you protect against spam? I never see a bunch of spam here, so you're obviously catching it in some manner.
~jon
Post a question that has something to with the topic of a blog post you're working on and get people talking about it. I use Kwippy for this since it's tailored so well toward discussion, but you could use Twitter, or even Seesmic.
When you've completely fleshed out your idea with the help of your social network post a link to all of them so they can see the finished product. Often more discussion will follow.
Thanks - M
Heck, even if I was a long time blogger I would have found this useful.
I'm teaching a class on blogs as they relate to professional development to a bunch of college seniors soon and this post is going to be required reading for them - you've saved me a hand out. Thanks!
I think that you have cover the content in this posting thorough enough so that anyone can get some helpful information from it.
go to <a href="http://six9k9.tripod.com for non-topic related blogs" rel="nofollow">Other Blogs
Which brings me to the question ... which system are you using Chris? I have accounts on several systems with this same email address I used to post and I can't figure out why I have a generic avatar here ;-)
Thanks ... Scott
What do you think about video commenting? What are the rules and will it soon overtake the traditional text commenting? Just curious as to your thoughts and why you don't offer it on your site. Love the post by the way I learned some great tid bits.
Yes I do agree, I tend to write from the Nerd perspective, given this is my penchant :-) I just declared on Twitter that I was Silver Iodide and going to seed the Cloud as the Rainmaker. Everytime I add comments I realise I'm another step further from reality...
Will definitely have to work on applying "idea handles" to my posts as I love the concept.
Also: "Please spammer, don't hurt 'em" = classic.
T
I am slowly starting to reap the benefits of getting involved in comments and that's not just people following what you write. They should make you question what you write.
I recently installed disqus on my blog and the number of comments left has increased significantly. I am now looking at improving the whole content of the site and particularly my blog area that drives my site and content.
Comments add a valuable element of discourse, there's no point in putting an idea out there if you're not willing to take on board other ideas. How are you going to hear these other ideas of you don't encourage comments?
Here's to comments.
@Chris, always ending with, please add your comments, like you do helps
@Derek great three points, important one is: On your own blog, respond to comments, your readers will love you (this would be hard for chris with so many comments)
If you're commenting, read all the comments already there, don't duplicate what someone else has already said with out recognition of their comment
Add value to the blog post you're commenting on
@Scott Aikin: I think timing is really valuable, I was involved in commenting on a post by Robert Scoble before anyone else was there, it resulted in lots of traffic, twitter ads and conversations (being first is great, pity I'm late in on this one :P)
Thanks for your strategies/tactics Chris
Good motto: Comment first, blog later.
Really just dropping in to say how much I appreciate all the free and valuable advice. I'm telling my Gov 2.0 friends that they should be reading and copying what you do, because what we are trying to do is build community and you're showing us the way. Appreciate it, as always.
An effective way I've generated comments is by offering contests. I have an internet marketing blog but prior to working in digital marketing I worked in Radio for 4 years and learned that people absolutely love to win free stuff. I always integrate my contests into something that corresponds with my blog posts. Here are some examples. I posted the links for easy access.
1. I wrote a new years blog about Online Marketing Education. I asked people to comment with their biggest marketing challenges in 2008 and what they plan to do about it in 2009. Everyone who commented was entered to win a free pass to the Online Marketing Summit: http://www.marketingmelodie.com/index.php/2009/...
2. I just posted a blog about the Inauguration exhibit at Legoland California. I am asking people for marketing ideas on increasing attendance at theme parks in a down economy. Everyone who leaves a comment is entered to win a free pair of tickets to Legoland http://www.marketingmelodie.com/index.php/2009/...
I just started doing this and the unique visits to my blog have more than doubled. I plan to do at least 1 contest everyone month. So ultimately I'm recommending that you offer an incentive but make sure that it ties into the blog post somehow.
Hope this helps! I wasn't able to read through your 100+ comments (got through about 40) so I'm not sure if someone else already had this tip.
Best,
Melodie
@MyMelodie
Whenever I do research for an article, post or tech I invariably end up reading a few blog posts. I ALWAYS leave a comment on all blogs I read. I get nearly 1/3 of my traffic from blogs in which I have left a comment. My best blog traffic comes from Problogger! (*Don't everyone rush over there to spam him...shame on you for thinking it.)
Think like Pollyanna! You can always find something nice to say about a post. Being negative or insulting is just plain easy and simple minded. Even if you feel you need to correct something in the post...make it an Oreo (I love Oreos don't you?). The chocolate cookies are the positive comments and the cream is the carefully constructed correction. Remember you could be wrong too!
Thanks for the great post...now I must go check my spam filter :)
Blessings,
Wendy Merritt
Twitter: WendyMerritt
So how do you put a "leave comment" link at the top of your post? I like to use as many interaction plugins to my blog like wp thread, comment luv, edit your comment, and so on. I found you through Google Alerts, the phrase "Comment Luv" seems to do the trick. Thanks for the read
~Expect Miracles
Fabietto
Otherwise, I try to add something that perhaps the post left out.
IMO blogging is truly another form of social networking. It is not simply a tool for the blogger to "preach to the masses."
There needs to be interaction with the readers.
However, that being said, those who do comment should NOT be adding their comments solely for the hopes of "being discovered"
I LOVE reading my favorite blogs and leaving comments allows me to interact with the blogger.
IMO blogging is truly another form of social networking. It is not simply a tool for the blogger to "preach to the masses."
There needs to be interaction with the readers.
However, that being said, those who do comment should NOT be adding their comments solely for the hopes of "being discovered"
I LOVE reading my favorite blogs and leaving comments allows me to interact with the blogger.
Nathan
For more from Mark check out his blog at:
http://msco.com/blog/customer-service-in-search...
Also, look for my full review of his seminar next Monday on http://www.applesassy.com
Steve
that's awesome how it worked out for you, it pays to comment and of course reply back =]
Making my comments dofollow
Using the Keywordluv plugin
Using the commentluv plugin
Reciprocating all comments
Making it easy for people to use links in their comments etc.
I've noticed that these all help to encourage people to share what they have to say.
--
To what extent do you think you can influence the sentiment of a discussion, if you are amongst the first to post?
If you wish to comment on my comment why now find me on @thewikiartist
--
Mr Brogan you have done it again - a post about comments that inspires lots of people to comment. What will you think of next? You have already written a post about inspiring people to follow you on Twitter that, unsurprisingly got lots of people to follow you on Twitter.
Could you perhaps write a post about how it is a good idea to leave track backs? wait you have that covered.
General wondering....how important is it to write about social media to be successful in social media?
Now if only I had something interesting to say...
I don't have an active blog like yours...I simply don't think I have that many fresh things to share, and I've never wanted to make it my goal. It's just a space to share things that interest me from time to time. But I moderate all my comments, and I'm a bit harsher about approving "empty shell" comments. I think you owe your readers (and substantive commenters) similar respect. I believe it's too easy to let the other stuff just flow by. Just my two cents' worth!
On the other hand, it's like a little piece of digital graffiti (albeit with links) that shows others who's come by. You see your own name, the names of your colleagues, and it sparks a kind of "we all hang out here" kind of thing.
I think this is important. What do you think?
As for Lori's problem w/gay Catholics, perhaps she could create a group for them to join in which they can select from avatars and nicknames so their real names and pics remain anonymous.
Molly
Chris' remark about gay Catholics was in reference to another blogger.
Molly
Also, thanks for the tip on spam filters. Never thought of that one. Heading over to check my spam box now.
I currently have a registration on my new blog... I used to run a BB on my site but kept getting thousands of spammers advertising unmentionables and I don't particularly want that to start happening on my blog. Is there another way to prevent that so I can turn off the registration?